Home       Site Map      Archives      Search      Bio & Photos       FAQs       Links       Contact       Get Brent       Help

 

Want more?  Check the archives!

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

"Joe Millionaire"

Is Any Reality Concept Too Bizarre?

Week of December 11, 2002

 

            “Joe Millionaire,” a seven episode mini-series debuting on Fox next month, should be a natural.  Start with ABC’s hit “The Bachelor,” rev up the greed and lust, mix in a good dose of deceit, and you have the general idea.

            The show was filmed in France, a location chosen to help keep the premise secret.  There, 20 single women flown in by Fox met a millionaire American bachelor to date their way through local landmarks while being winnowed down “Bachelor” style.  The project was so hush-hush that less than a half dozen of the network’s honchos knew it existed.  Even the film crew wasn’t told exactly what they were shooting.

            Why the cloak-and-dagger shtick?  The hook is that “Joe Millionaire” isn’t; he is actually a construction worker who knocks down about 19 grand a year.  He reveals this only after choosing the winner, though the television audience will be in on the gag all along.

            What a hoot.  I assume the producers screened the contestants to select only those with scrawny big brothers. 

            Although reality show contestants certainly expect to be jerked around, this seems plain mean.  Not so says Fox reality programming boss Mike Darnell, who claims the network just wants to know “whether they’re really doing this for love,” as if that were a great mystery. 

             “We get to see if she (the winner) still wants to be with him” after the big lie, Darnell continued.  She’d not only have to be unconcerned about the imaginary millions, character can’t be high on her list either.  Scratch those and I’m not sure what’s left. 

            At least “Joe Millionaire” won’t be a continuing series.  “We cannot duplicate this show.  It’s a one-time only thing,” admits Fox Entertainment president Gail Berman, and for obvious reasons.  Once women are on to the joke, few are likely to risk being the butt of it.

            “Joe” leaves one wondering whether there is any concept too cruel or bizarre for reality programming.  I tried conjuring up a few in a column I wrote after Fox aired “Who Wants to Marry a Multi-Millionaire?” in February 2000, tossing out ideas I thought just daft enough to illustrate the absurdity of the genre.  You can probably guess the rest: Some of those brainstorms have since come dangerously close to reality show reality. 

            NBC’s “Fear Factor” looks suspiciously like my “Who Wants to be a Stuntman?”, a program that would have had daredevils perform increasingly hazardous stunts until someone lost a spleen.   Media tycoon Rupert Murdoch almost certainly stole “American Candidate,” a show under development in which the winner will become a U.S. presidential candidate, from my “Who Wants To Be A Despot?”  My show made the runner-up a presidential candidate; the winner got a third world country.  I suppose that is beyond even Murdoch’s financial grasp.    

            My “Who Wants to Have Plastic Surgery?” idea was brought to life this month as ABC’s “Extreme Makeover,” a reality facelift program so close I ought to get royalties. 

            Not all of my ideas have been flattered by imitation, yet, but the only one I’d bet against is “Who Wants To See Quality News And Entertainment On Broadcast Television?”  It might seem the answer is “No one,” but maybe the success of today’s hot shows has been overblown.

            The Los Angeles Times reports that the top rated television series of the current season is watched in only 17.6 percent of households with televisions.  This is the culmination of a downward spiral from the days when “I Love Lucy” drew 67.3 percent. 

            Of course viewers have a lot more choices now, one of which is still to turn off the TV.  That might be the best reality of all.

            On Brentmorrison.com:  Links to related news; Brent’s 2000 column on reality show concepts.

 

 

 

 
 

 

Email Brent:

 

Brent@brentmorrison.com

 

 

 

Latest columns:

   
 

Getting the most hits:

 
 

Need an antidote to "Harmful to Minors"?

(See column

Try Rae Turnbull's excellent "Be the Parent Your Child Deserves"

 
 

Get Brent

in your local paper.

Click here!

 
 

Hear Brent

speak to your community group, church, fundraiser, or business group.  Click here.

   

 

 

 

© 2002 Brent Morrison